Dr Walsh on Selecting a Surgeon for Your PCa

Johns Hopkins Health Alert

Advice From Dr. Walsh on Finding the Right Prostate Cancer Surgeon
Comments (1)





Dr. Patrick Walsh, former director of Johns Hopkins’s Brady Urological Institute, shares his insights on choosing a doctor for your cancer surgery.

Dr. Patrick Walsh, dean of prostate cancer surgeons, has performed the technically challenging radical prostatectomy procedure thousands of times, and has personally schooled hundreds of surgeons in the finer points of the difficult nerve-sparing cancer operation. He certainly knows what it takes to be an expert in curing a man of cancer, preserving bladder function, and maintaining the nerves responsible for erections. What about the doctor you’re considering for your own prostate cancer surgery?

“Your doctor may be nice and personable,” says Dr. Walsh, “a practitioner whose empathy for your condition appeals to you, which is great. But what do you know about him? He’s got a terrific bedside manner, but is he a board-certified urologist? What training has he had? Does he know and use the nerve-sparing cancer surgery techniques -- the anatomical approach to radical prostatectomy? How many of these cancer surgeries does he perform annually? What success has he had in preserving potency and continence? If he can’t or won’t give you his rate of success as compared to reports from other surgeons, or to results published in medical journals, this may be a red flag, and perhaps you should look elsewhere for your cancer surgeon.

“You should be able to get a good idea of his success rate in numbers or percentages. In addition, if he hasn’t done very many of these cancer operations -- ideally, hundreds -- you might want to find a more experienced surgeon. Look at it this way: Do you want to be one of the patients he’s learning on? Do you want to be part of someone’s learning curve?


“Remember: You don’t want a surgeon who’s ‘pretty good’ at removing the prostate. There are no second chances here: This is a one-shot operation. You are looking for the one surgeon who will perform the one radical prostatectomy you will ever receive in your life, the one operation that will cure your cancer.

“You want a surgeon who is going to make sure that no cancer is left behind, and who knows how to minimize trauma to your body during surgery so you don’t wind up with incontinence, erectile dysfunction, or both.

“Finding the right surgeon may mean that you must travel to a major medical center in another city. This may mean that you’ll be away from home for four days. But after that, even though you may need to wear a catheter for a week or two, the recovery from the operation is usually speedy, and follow- up communication can be carried out over the telephone.